CWE-421: Race Condition During Access to Alternate Channel

What is Race Condition During Access to Alternate Channel?

• Overview: Race Condition During Access to Alternate Channel occurs when a software product opens a communication channel intended for authorized users, but this channel can be accessed by unauthorized users due to a timing issue.

• Exploitation Methods:

• Attackers exploit this vulnerability by timing their access attempts to gain control of the channel before the authorized user.
• Common attack patterns include exploiting predictable timing of channel openings and using automated tools to rapidly attempt access.

• Security Impact:

• Direct consequences of successful exploitation include unauthorized access to sensitive information or systems.
• Potential cascading effects include further system compromise and data breaches.
• Business impact can involve loss of customer trust, legal implications, and financial losses due to data breaches or service disruptions.

• Prevention Guidelines:

• Specific code-level fixes include implementing proper synchronization mechanisms and ensuring exclusive access to the channel.
• Security best practices involve thorough testing for race conditions, using locks or semaphores, and auditing access control mechanisms.
• Recommended tools and frameworks include using static analysis tools to identify potential race conditions and employing libraries that manage concurrency effectively.

Corgea can automatically detect and fix Race Condition During Access to Alternate Channel in your codebase. Try Corgea free today.

Technical Details

Likelihood of Exploit: Not specified

Affected Languages: Not Language-Specific

Affected Technologies: Not specified

Vulnerable Code Example

Python Example

import threading

class SecureChannel:
    def __init__(self):
        self.channel_open = False
        self.channel_data = None

    def open_channel(self, user):
        if user.is_authorized():  # Check if user is authorized
            self.channel_open = True
            # Simulate some delay
            threading.Thread(target=self._simulate_delay).start()
            self.channel_data = "Sensitive Data"  # This assignment is vulnerable
            print("Channel opened for authorized user.")
        else:
            print("User not authorized.")

    def _simulate_delay(self):
        import time
        time.sleep(1)
        self.channel_open = False

# Vulnerable scenario: race condition allows unauthorized access to channel_data

Explanation:

• In the above code, an authorized user opens a communication channel using the open_channel method.
• A race condition occurs because the channel remains open (self.channel_open = True) for a short time before being closed asynchronously by _simulate_delay.
• During this window, an attacker could potentially access self.channel_data if they know the channel is open, exploiting the delay introduced by _simulate_delay.

How to fix Race Condition During Access to Alternate Channel?

To fix this vulnerability, ensure that access to sensitive data through the alternate channel is strictly controlled and synchronized. Use locks to prevent race conditions, ensuring that only authorized operations can proceed while the channel is open. Also, minimize the time window in which the channel is open.

Fixed Code Example

import threading

class SecureChannel:
    def __init__(self):
        self.channel_open = False
        self.channel_data = None
        self.lock = threading.Lock()  # Initialize a lock for synchronization

    def open_channel(self, user):
        if user.is_authorized():
            with self.lock:  # Acquire lock to ensure exclusive access
                self.channel_open = True
                self.channel_data = "Sensitive Data"  # Assign data within lock context
                print("Channel opened for authorized user.")
                self._process_data()  # Process data immediately to minimize exposure
                self.channel_open = False  # Close channel immediately after processing
        else:
            print("User not authorized.")

    def _process_data(self):
        # Process the sensitive data, ensuring it is handled securely
        print("Processing sensitive data...")
        # Simulate processing without unnecessary delay

Explanation:

• A Lock has been introduced to synchronize access to the channel (self.lock).
• The open_channel method now uses a with self.lock statement to ensure that the critical section where the channel is open is executed atomically.
• The channel is opened, sensitive data is processed, and then the channel is closed immediately within the lock's scope, reducing the window for potential exploits.
• This synchronization ensures that unauthorized access attempts are effectively blocked during the channel's open state.

Fixed Code Example