CWE-1422: Exposure of Sensitive Information caused by Incorrect Data Forwarding during Transient Execution

What is Exposure of Sensitive Information caused by Incorrect Data Forwarding during Transient Execution?

• Overview: Exposure of Sensitive Information caused by Incorrect Data Forwarding during Transient Execution (CWE-1422) occurs when a processor forwards incorrect or stale data to transient operations, allowing data leakage through covert channels. This can undermine software memory safety and isolation expectations.

• Exploitation Methods:

• Attackers can exploit this vulnerability by triggering transient execution in a victim process, causing it to access and expose sensitive data.
• Common attack patterns include timing attacks and side-channel attacks to observe microarchitectural side effects that reveal data.

• Security Impact:

• Direct consequences include the exposure of sensitive information, such as private data within a process.
• Potential cascading effects involve breaking memory safety and isolation, leading to broader data breaches.
• Business impact includes loss of customer trust, potential legal implications, and financial loss due to data breaches.

• Prevention Guidelines:

• Specific code-level fixes involve implementing strict memory access controls and avoiding assumptions about processor behavior.
• Security best practices include regularly updating systems with patches that address microarchitectural vulnerabilities.
• Recommended tools and frameworks are those that enforce memory safety and provide robust sandboxing mechanisms, such as memory-safe languages and secure compiler options.

Corgea can automatically detect and fix Exposure of Sensitive Information caused by Incorrect Data Forwarding during Transient Execution in your codebase. [Try Corgea free today](https://corgea.app).

Technical Details

Likelihood of Exploit: Not specified

Affected Languages: Not Language-Specific

Affected Technologies: Not Technology-Specific

Vulnerable Code Example

import os

def process_data(user_input):
    secret_key = "TOP_SECRET_KEY"  # Sensitive data that should be protected

    # Vulnerability: Incorrect data handling leading to potential exposure of sensitive information.
    # During transient execution, speculative execution could potentially expose `secret_key`.
    # This occurs because the value of secret_key is conditionally changed based on user input.
    if "admin" in user_input:
        secret_key = os.environ.get("ADMIN_SECRET_KEY", "DEFAULT_SECRET")
    
    # Inefficient data processing that might lead to speculative execution paths
    return secret_key if secret_key else "No secret key found"

How to fix Exposure of Sensitive Information caused by Incorrect Data Forwarding during Transient Execution?

To mitigate the risk of speculative execution vulnerabilities, such as those exploited by Spectre and Meltdown, sensitive data should be handled in a way that does not allow it to be exposed through incorrect prediction paths.

Fix Approach:

1. Avoid Speculative Execution of Sensitive Data: Ensure sensitive data is not accessed conditionally based on user input that could be speculated.
2. Use Constant-Time Operations: Implement constant-time operations to prevent timing attacks and speculative execution leaks.
3. Limit Conditional Access: Avoid changing sensitive data based on user-controlled inputs.

Fixed Code Example

import os

def process_data(user_input):
    # Securely fetch secret key from environment, avoiding speculative execution paths
    secret_key = os.environ.get("TOP_SECRET_KEY", "DEFAULT_SECRET")
    
    # Avoid speculative execution: Do not modify sensitive data based on user-controlled input
    # Instead, use a secure access method that does not rely on speculative paths
    if "admin" in user_input:
        # Fetch admin key securely, outside of any speculative execution paths
        admin_key = os.environ.get("ADMIN_SECRET_KEY", "DEFAULT_SECRET")
        return admin_key
    
    return secret_key

Explanation of Fixes:

• Secure Environment Fetch: Sensitive keys are fetched directly from a secure source, such as environment variables, at the start of the function to avoid any conditional fetching based on user inputs.
• Avoid Conditional Key Modification: The code avoids altering sensitive data based on conditions that could lead to speculative execution, thereby preventing exposure of sensitive data.
• Constant-Time Operations: While not explicitly shown here, it's important to ensure that operations involving sensitive data are executed in constant time to mitigate timing attacks. This can be implemented with libraries or techniques that ensure consistent execution time regardless of input.