CWE-1339: Insufficient Precision or Accuracy of a Real Number

What is Insufficient Precision or Accuracy of a Real Number?

• Overview: This vulnerability occurs when a software product handles real numbers in a way that does not maintain the necessary precision and accuracy, particularly in the fractional part. This can result in incorrect calculations, especially in scenarios requiring high precision like financial applications.

• Exploitation Methods:

• Attackers can exploit this by manipulating numbers to cause errors in calculations, leading to incorrect outputs or decisions.
• Common attack patterns include precision-related exploits where attackers input specially crafted values to force rounding errors or inaccuracies in calculations.

• Security Impact:

• Direct consequences include incorrect calculations, which could lead to financial discrepancies, misreported data, or flawed decision-making processes.
• Potential cascading effects involve compromised integrity of dependent systems and erroneous outcomes in automated processes.
• Business impact could be significant, particularly in financial sectors, leading to loss of trust, financial loss, or regulatory penalties.

• Prevention Guidelines:

• Specific code-level fixes include using data types and libraries designed for high-precision arithmetic, such as arbitrary-precision libraries.
• Security best practices involve validating inputs rigorously, using fixed-point arithmetic when possible, and performing thorough testing for precision-related issues.
• Recommended tools and frameworks include those offering arbitrary precision arithmetic like BigDecimal in Java or the Decimal module in Python, which help maintain precision and accuracy in calculations.

Corgea can automatically detect and fix Insufficient Precision or Accuracy of a Real Number in your codebase. [Try Corgea free today](https://corgea.app).

Technical Details

Likelihood of Exploit: Not specified

Affected Languages: Not Language-Specific

Affected Technologies: Not Technology-Specific

There are three major ways to store real numbers in computers. Each method is described along with the limitations of how they store their numbers.

Fixed: Some implementations use a fixed number of binary bits to represent both the integer and the fraction. In the demonstrative example about Muller's Recurrence, the fraction 108.0 - ((815.0 - 1500.0 / z) / y) cannot be represented in 8 binary digits. The numeric accuracy within languages such as PL/1, COBOL and Ada is expressed in decimal digits rather than binary digits. In SQL and most databases, the length of the integer and the fraction are specified by the programmer in decimal. In the language C, fixed reals are implemented according to ISO/IEC TR18037 Floating: The number is stored in a version of scientific notation with a fixed length for the base and the significand. This allows flexibility for more accuracy when the integer portion is smaller. When dealing with large integers, the fractional accuracy is less. Languages such as PL/1, COBOL and Ada set the accuracy by decimal digit representation rather than using binary digits. Python also implements decimal floating-point numbers using the IEEE 754-2008 encoding method. Ratio: The number is stored as the ratio of two integers. These integers also have their limits. These integers can be stored in a fixed number of bits or in a vector of digits. While the vector of digits method provides for very large integers, they cannot truly represent a repeating or transcendental number as those numbers do not ever have a fixed length.

Vulnerable Code Example

def calculate_interest(principal, rate, years):
    # Vulnerable: Using float for precise financial calculations
    # Floats can introduce small errors due to precision limitations
    # This can lead to incorrect interest calculations over time
    interest = principal * (1 + rate) ** years
    return round(interest, 2)

principal = 1000.0
rate = 0.05
years = 10
print(f"Total amount after {years} years: {calculate_interest(principal, rate, years)}")

Explanation

In the vulnerable code example, the calculate_interest function uses float to perform financial calculations. While float is suitable for many applications, it can introduce rounding errors due to its binary representation, which is not ideal for precise calculations like those needed in financial applications. This could lead to incorrect total amounts being calculated over time.

How to fix Insufficient Precision or Accuracy of a Real Number?

To address the precision issue in financial calculations, it is crucial to use the Decimal type from Python's decimal module. The Decimal type provides arbitrary precision arithmetic, which is essential for accurate financial calculations.

Key Fixes:

1. Replace the float type with the Decimal type for all monetary values and calculations.
2. Import the Decimal class from the decimal module.
3. Use Decimal in calculations to avoid precision errors common with floating-point arithmetic.

Fixed Code Example

from decimal import Decimal  # Import the Decimal class

def calculate_interest(principal, rate, years):
    # Fixed: Using Decimal for precise financial calculations
    # Decimal maintains precision and avoids small errors
    principal = Decimal(principal)  # Convert principal to Decimal
    rate = Decimal(rate)  # Convert rate to Decimal
    interest = principal * (1 + rate) ** years  # Calculate interest using Decimal
    return round(interest, 2)  # Round the result to two decimal places

principal = '1000.0'  # Use strings to ensure precision with Decimal
rate = '0.05'
years = 10
print(f"Total amount after {years} years: {calculate_interest(principal, rate, years)}")

Explanation

In the fixed code example, the Decimal type is used for all calculations involving real numbers. By converting the input values to Decimal, we ensure that the calculations maintain precision and avoid the potential errors associated with floating-point arithmetic. This approach is crucial in applications where precision is important, such as financial calculations. Additionally, using strings for initialization ensures that the Decimal constructor maintains the exact precision needed.